You are Here > Home > Borrowing > Moves to address reckless lending

Moves to address reckless lending

Jun 16, 2013

Changes to the National Credit Act are necessary to deal with reckless lending, but proposed amendments may have unintended consequences.

NCR-LogoThe Department of Trade and Industry recently proposed amendments to the National Credit Act to deal with reckless lending.

One of these amendments proposes that the National Credit Regulator be allowed to refer credit agreements to the National Consumer Tribunal to be declared reckless.

Currently the National Credit Act requires that cases of reckless lending be identified by a debt counselor who in turn needs to bring the case before the courts. This has created a significant burden for debt counselors and is cited as one of the reasons why there have been so few charges of reckless lending. The NCR currently can only refer a credit provider to the Tribunal for reckless lending on the basis that the credit provider has engaged in conduct prohibited by the National Credit Act.

The new proposal would see consumers being able to contact the National Credit Regulator directly with credit agreements they believe to have been entered into recklessly. The NCR would investigate and if the claim is believed to be valid, it would refer the case directly to the Tribunal.

While this proposal is aimed at trying to find a more expedient manner in dealing with reckless lending cases, this move would increase the volumes of complaints and the number of investigations handled by the National Credit Regulator.

Lesiba Mashapa, company secretary at the NCR, says the regulator is confident that they have both the call centre and legal capacity to handle individual consumer complaints.

The NCR has also invited comments on its draft affordability assessment guidelines. The guidelines include a proposal that credit providers refrain from lending to the maximum of the consumers’ discretionary income and leave a margin of 25% to cater for unexpected changes in the consumers’ financial circumstances.

This effectively means that individuals will only be able to borrow amounts where the repayment does not exceed 75% of their discretionary income. In this case discretionary income is defined as being that which is left over after you have paid for your taxes and basic living expenses such as rent, electricity and food. The guidelines will also require that reasonable amounts are used to calculate these basic living expenses so that people cannot understate their expenses in order to maximise their affordability. Default amounts would apply and the onus would be on the applicant to prove otherwise. “There are also many instances where credit providers lend to the maximum of the consumers’ discretionary income, leaving no margin for consumers to meet unexpected expenses,” Mashapa says.

The actual definition of discretionary income will be a challenge as it needs to be determined which expenses would be included in the calculation – for example insurance and school fees. While this move may prevent regulated lenders from providing credit to people who cannot afford it, there are concerns that this will not address the issue of over-indebtedness as it could simply see a shift to loan sharks who work outside the system.

Many people borrow money simply to survive and if unable to borrow from a registered lender they may have no option but to opt for more expensive loans from unscrupulous lenders. As loan sharks use tactics such as keeping people’s ATM cards to ensure they are paid first, this could see a knock-on effect of higher default levels for regulated lenders who will be paid last. Mashapa indicates that the NCR is continuing to stamp out these practices and many lenders were arrested by the police and also referred to the Tribunal by the NCR for these abusive practices.

While solutions need to be found to address South Africa’s unsustainable indebtedness levels, there is no act or law that will stop desperate people from accessing loans. The only real solution is economic growth and job creation.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Maya Fisher-French author of Money Questions Answered

Previous Articles

In search of a low-cost credit card

For the last 14 years I have been the happy owner of a Virgin Money credit card. The card has zero annual fees which made it a perfect credit card to hold for emergencies rather than using for day-to-day spending. In my case I also used it for booking travel such as...

Making the home loan process less painful

Buying a home can be a very emotional experience. You’ve found the home of your dreams and imagined yourself living there, and then you take the financial leap of committing yourself to a home loan and years of repayments. Yet the home loan application and transfer...

Listen: Know the difference between good, bad and ugly credit

Is there such a thing as good credit? What forms of credit should you avoid at all cost? In this podcast, Maya (@mayaonmoney) and Mapalo (@womanandfinance) discuss the good and dark side of credit and whether the concept of the lay-by will come back into fashion as...

Video: Pay back that payment holiday

We've seen many financial institutions offer their customers a debt payment holiday during these trying times. And while it may seem like a welcome relief, be careful because it might end up costing you a lot more than you realize. According to the Old Mutual Savings...

How to save for your goals to avoid debt

One of the main reasons we have a credit crisis in South Africa is that we never plan and save towards our goals, because it’s just easier to borrow. Change your dependency on credit by planning for those money moments and start saving for your short-term goals in a...

Q&A: Interest rates

We’ve had significant cuts in the interest rate this year. On 1 January 2020, the prime interest rate was 10%, and as of 22 May, it had been reduced to 7.25%. The current repo rate of 3.75% is the lowest it's been for almost 47 years. So it's not surprising that many...

Listen: Beware the payment-holiday trap

Payment holidays are a lot like real holidays – they end up costing more than you realise. In this podcast, Maya (@mayaonmoney) and Mapalo (@womanandfinance) look at the costs of debt-payment holidays and how to get back on track after taking one.

Video: When to use the budget facility on your credit card

If you are a regular watcher of Money Matters you will know that the best way to manage a credit card is to pay it off in full at the end of each month. A credit card acts as a revolving loan. If you are only paying off the minimum instalment required each month, it...

Loan scheme now available for small businesses

National Treasury recently announced that it had provided a guarantee of R100bn to banks to provide additional funding for small businesses. This will be increased to R200bn if it is necessary and the Scheme is successful. “This guaranteed loan scheme will bolster...

What to do if your debt counsellor goes AWOL

If your debt counsellor is not registered, or not contactable, or not providing you the required service, then you can transfer to another debt counsellor.  All you have to do is approach a new debt counsellor and complete the application form. It will then take about...

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This