You are Here > Home > Financial planning > Retirement annuity tax loophole to be closed

Retirement annuity tax loophole to be closed

Jul 11, 2015

By Tanya Lochner, fiduciary specialist at Glacier by Sanlam

In the foreseeable future retirement annuities will no longer fall outside of your estate for estate duty purposes, so bear that in mind when you do your estate planning.

RA Tax LoopholeSince 2007, a retirement annuity (RA) has been a tax-favourable savings vehicle in that the lump sums were not subject to estate duty and executor fees.

A number of intermediaries advise their clients to put substantial amounts of money into a retirement annuity because the proceeds, no matter how large the amount, can go to their beneficiaries without being subject to estate duty. Clients can also contribute to an RA and retire (note that the minimum age of retirement from an RA is age 55) the very next year – in which case they will be allowed to take one third as a lump sum and not pay any income tax on that amount because of their contribution in the previous year that has not been deducted from income tax yet. The remaining disallowed portion can be deducted from the income generated in the annuity purchased with the remaining two thirds.

Closing the loophole

For these reasons, RAs are often used for tax planning purposes rather than as a retirement vehicle, which is traditionally how they should be used.

Let’s use an example: Sean contributes a lump sum of R50 million into an RA. When Sean passes away his beneficiary would be allowed to take the proceeds as a lump sum, or convert the proceeds into a life annuity or opt for a combination of both of these options. If the beneficiary chooses to convert a portion or the whole amount into an annuity, he will unfortunately not be able to deduct the remaining disallowed portion from the income generated in the annuity purchased. Sean’s estate, however, would also not be liable for estate duty on the RA.

The National Treasury intends to close this loophole and the proposal is to subject any disallowed portion that’s left on the day the client passes away, to estate duty. So if Sean contributed R50 million towards an RA and he could deduct R25 million in terms of the threshold of his tax bracket by the time he passes away, the additional R25 million that he wasn’t able to deduct will now form part of his estate and may be subject to estate duty.

The proposed changes in tax on RAs haven’t come into effect yet, and some intermediaries may consider this to be a window of opportunity and advise their clients to invest a lump sum into an RA while there’s still time.

However, the National Treasury could possibly apply the changes retrospectively. It’s important to have your records ready to explain why the decision to take out an RA was made in the first place; you might need to prove that it wasn’t just for the tax benefit.

Although RAs may no longer provide the full tax benefit as far as estate planning is concerned, there are still good reasons to invest lump sums into this savings vehicle. While your client is alive he or she may still claim the disallowed portions from tax. If they withdraw the lump sum from the RA upon retirement and take out a living annuity, they may still deduct a percentage from the income that descends from the living annuity. The proposed changes in tax are currently not carried over to an annuity purchased with proceeds after retirement which still presents an opportunity for clients to save on tax.

More changes

Other retirement changes are also on the cards and will be implemented on 1 March 2016. These include the deductible contributions to retirement funds that will be applicable to pension and provident funds as well as RAs.

The portion you may deduct from your retirement fund will be the lesser of 27,5% of the greater remuneration or taxable income, or R350 000 – so the amount you can contribute (for tax-benefit purposes) will be capped.


Sean is a member of a defined contribution fund. His total remuneration package is R500 000 per annum and he and his employer each contribute R50 000 a year to his pension fund. In addition, Sean contributes R60 000 per year to an RA.

Sean’s total contribution to his retirement funds is R160 000 (R50 000 + R50 000 + R60 000). The maximum amount he may deduct from his contributions for tax purposes is therefore 27,5% of his annual salary, which amounts to R137 500.

This means Sean contributes more than he’s able to deduct for tax purposes. However, he’s allowed to deduct the difference of R22 500 (R160 000-R137 500) in the following tax year.

If Sean exceeds the percentage he’s allowed to deduct from tax again, it will roll over to the next year. If he is again not allowed to deduct his full contribution amount from tax, it will roll over again. These rollover amounts will be available when he exits the fund or passes away. He’ll then be allowed to deduct them from the lump sum before paying tax on the lump sum when he exits the fund.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Maya Fisher-French author of Money Questions Answered

Previous Articles

Self-service facility for GEPF members

Technology is making it easier for GEPF members and pensioners to keep track of their pension information and claims process. By downloading the new GEPF self-service mobile app onto your device, you can remove the frustration of standing in long queues at GEPF...

Treasury’s solution to early withdrawal

As part of its ongoing retirement reform process, National Treasury is proposing the introduction of a two-bucket retirement system to provide for shorter and longer-term needs. John Anderson, executive at Alexander Forbes, says it may work along the same percentages...

The NSSF will not meet the needs of South Africans

While noble in its aim, the establishment of a National Social Security Fund (NSSF) is largely unworkable. In August, the department of Social Development issued a Green Paper on Comprehensive Social Security and Retirement Reform, which outlined a “super fund” to...

Do you have an unclaimed benefit with the GEPF?

The Government Employees Pension Fund (GEPF) is concerned with the increase in the number of unclaimed benefits and wants to pay them out. If you are a former government employee who did not claim a pension on retirement, it is possible that you have money owed to...

Nothing shocking about new retirement fund emigration rules

South Africans seem to live in constant fear of the government going after their savings. New tax rules for emigrants' retirement funds is just the latest development to fuel this anxiety. Andre Tuck, Senior Investment Consultant at 10X Investments, has a close look...

Proposed additional exit tax leaves industry experts confused

Tax Consulting SA gives the lowdown on a new draft tax bill which essentially proposes an additional exit tax on retirement funds. It is not uncommon for National Treasury and the South African Revenue Services (SARS) to propose, and subsequently gazette, amendments...

GEPF establishes complaints handling office

If you are struggling to get your claims processed or not receiving your benefits, help is at hand with the recent establishment of the Government Employees Pension Ombud (GEPO). The state is the largest employer in the country, and the Government Employees Pension...

More households supporting unemployed family

For many working South Africans, the pressure of financially supporting friends and family is unrelenting. Most of us have either experienced a job loss or have a family member who lost an income due to the extended Covid-19 lockdown. It is not surprising then that...

What is screen scraping and is it safe?

Screen scraping can be used by criminals to steal data, but financial services companies are increasingly making legitimate use of this too. Angelique Ruzicka investigates what the process entails and how consumers can protect themselves. Screen scraping can be hugely...

Retirement planning is not a once-off event

Jaco Prinsloo, Wealth Manager at PPS Wealth Advisory, has some sensible advice around retirement planning. As a wealth manager, I have observed that there are two typical clients. Some dread retirement, while others look forward to it. Those who dread it are the ones...

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This