You are Here > Home > My Insurance > Why motor insurance claims are disputed

Why motor insurance claims are disputed

Jul 1, 2019

Why motor insurance claims are disputedWhen the Ombudsman for Short-Term Insurance (OSTI) released its annual report recently, it was unsurprising that complaints around motor vehicle insurance are the most common, at over 48%.

Of these complaints, 18% of motor vehicle insurance disputes were resolved in favour of the insured and a total of R53 641 058 was ordered to be paid out.

We spoke to Ayanda Mazwi, Senior Assistant Ombudsman, to understand why motor insurance is so contentious.

Listen to Maya and Mapalo Makhu discussing this and other topics in the My Money, My Lifestyle podcast.

Mazwi said the majority of the complaints related to accidental damage and specifically the amount offered for the settlement of claims. In cases where a car is a write-off, the insurer will pay out the insured value of the car, and it is this insured value that is often in dispute.

Three options for valuing a vehicle

Mazwi said there are three values that you can use when insuring your vehicle – retail value, market value or  trade value. These all have different premium ratings and the cheaper your cover, the more likely it is that you are insured at the lower value.

Retail value is the amount that the car is likely to retail at – in other words the price you would pay to buy it. Mazwi says this is calculated using the Auto Dealers’ guide. The guide is an average guide to the retail price of the car, which means the same car could be on the market at a higher price. As this is the maximum amount you could be paid out for a car, premiums for insurance at retail value would be higher than if you insured at market value.

Market value is the lowest amount your car can be valued at. This is again based on the Auto Dealers’ guide and is usually the amount a dealer would pay for the car – not how much it would retail for.

Finally, there is the trade price which is between the market price and retail price and is usually how much you would be paid for a trade-in.

Mazwi says often during the sales process of the insurance policy, the car owner wants to get the lowest possible premium and therefore selects market value. However, when their car is written off in an accident, they then question why they have been paid out an amount which is too low for them to replace the vehicle.

Salvage value

Another contentious point is around the salvage value of the car. Mazwi says many clients are under the impression that they can get the full insurance pay-out and still keep the salvaged car, which they can then sell for spare parts or try to have repaired. However, if the insurer pays out the fully insured amount, the contract allows the insurer to keep the salvaged vehicle. “If the insurer pays out the full claim and the insured keeps the salvaged vehicle, they would have been enriched,” says Mazwi. The principle of insurance is that the insured cannot be in a better financial position than before the claim.

In some cases, the insured wishes to keep the salvaged vehicle and agrees to a lower claim amount. However, this also raises debates over the value of the salvaged car. In many cases the car owner feels the salvage is worth less than the insurer is deducting from the payout. Mazwi says retaining the salvage reduces the claim pay-out by 40% to 60% and is based on the general guidelines of the South African Insurance Association (SAIA). Mazwi says in most cases a customer is better off accepting the full claims payment than retaining the salvaged parts and accepting a lower payment.

Issues around warranties are also one of the main reasons for vehicle insurance disputes. Mazwi acknowledges that this is a problem in the industry where many of the extended warranty policies are too complex and technical for the ordinary consumer to understand. In some cases, the exclusions are so onerous the consumer has virtually no cover.

“We look at these matters very carefully, especially if the disclosure from the underwriter is not clear,” says Mazwi who adds that the regulation around ‘policy-holder protection rules’ is being introduced to ensure that these policies are more transparent and highlight the necessary information to customers.

In terms of their rulings, OSTI is only able to require the insurer to pay out the insured amount and not any consequential losses or damages incurred. For example, if you had to pay for a hire car or an Uber while waiting for your claim to be resolved, that would not be covered in OSTI’s ruling. However, Mazwi says in instances where the insurer was unreasonable and the claim dispute was not based on merit, or the insurer was seen to be obstructing the process, OSTI would consider awarding damages. However, this would be on a case-by-case basis.

Complaints in numbers

  • 65% of cases finalised within four months
  • 9 779 formal complaints lodged
  • 4 026 preliminary complaints received
  • 88 421 calls received by call centre
  • R87 250 982 in rand value resolved in favour of insured
  • 2% of complaints received related to motor insurance

Contact details:

The Ombudsman for Short Term Insurance: 1st Floor, Block A, 1 Sturdee Avenue, Rosebank, Johannesburg, 2196. Tel: +27 11 726 8900.

This article first appeared in City Press.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Maya Fisher-French author of Money Questions Answered

Previous Articles

Struggling with car debt? Take action now!

According to the Experian Consumer Default Index, repayment of car debt has shown a marked deterioration as the extended Covid-19 lockdown puts South Africans under more financial pressure. Marc Friedman, CEO of car sale platform says that to avoid a...

E-cigarettes and your life insurance policy

Clyde Parsons, Actuarial Executive at BrightRock, explains why regular users of e-cigarettes are charged smoker rates by life insurers, and what you can do about it. For decades now, we’ve known that smoking is bad for our health – the research has conclusively shown...

How to save on home loan insurance

When applying for a home loan, the bank will insist that you take out home loan insurance to cover the repayments in the event of death, disability, or retrenchment. Evelyn Doubell, Private Wealth Manager at NFB Wealth Management finds that it’s usually cheaper to...

Competition will cut car ownership costs

Freedom to have your car repaired by a non-dealer will increase competition and reduce the cost of repairing and insuring your car. A couple of years ago when I was buying a second-hand car that didn’t have a service plan, I discovered what a rip-off my dealership had...

Tips for a successful used car purchase

Ernest North, co-founder of AI-driven insurtech Naked, looks at some of the steps to follow before committing to a used car purchase. Numbers from TransUnion show that South Africans financed around 79 000 used vehicles in the first three months of 2021, with lenders...

Video: The true cost of a fancy car

The decision on how much to spend when purchasing your car is possibly one of your most important financial decisions. In fact, banks say that the main reason they turn down home loan applications is due to affordability, and the main culprit is usually car finance....

When does it make sense to have a travel allowance?

If you are required to travel for work there are several ways to claim for this expense. You can receive a travel allowance or be provided with a company car. In the case of a travel allowance, the employer would normally pay a set amount, for example R5 000 a month....

Fancy new car or a fabulous retirement?

Khwezi Jackson, investment consultant at 10X Investments, explains how buying a fancy new car could sabotage your retirement funding. Seeing a headline, ‘Spending R10,000 per month on a new car’, got me thinking: Why would anyone spend that much money every month to...

The best way to settle your car finance

Advance payments on car finance do not work the same as on your home loan, so it’s worth understanding how to make the most of it. Any debt that you pay off sooner than required will save you money on interest. However, you need to understand how advance payments work...

Court rules for insurer to pay up

The global shutdown in the face of the COVID-19 pandemic is testing the clauses of insurance policies – specifically business interruption insurance – with claimants and insurers across the world fighting it out in court. The Western Cape High Court recently issued a...

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This