You are Here > Home > Financial Sense Home > Should pensioners worry about interest-rate cuts?

Should pensioners worry about interest-rate cuts?

Aug 17, 2020

By Mica Townsend, Business Development Manager at 10X Investments

Should pensioners worry about interest-rate cuts?Most pensioners who live off interest from savings have had their incomes dramatically reduced by the interest-rate cuts of the last few months, but this is not the only ‒ or even the worst ‒ risk they face.

When the investment market melted down in March, those invested mainly in the money markets might have felt relieved to see their capital remain intact. That relief would have been short-lived, though. The repo rate, the rate at which the central bank lends money to commercial banks, has been cut by a total of 3% this year, which means that commercially available interest rates have almost halved since January.

Pensioners who are living off interest on their savings are now, like many other South Africans, feeling a lot poorer. They have seen their income shrink month on month without a likely commensurate decline in their living expenses.

It’s all about inflation

They aren’t really poorer, though ‒ at least not yet. These words may provide little comfort but, on the basis of the official inflation numbers, they are barely worse off than they were six months ago.

This is best illustrated by an example. Let’s assume a pensioner has cash savings of R1 million on which they earn interest at 7% p.a., paid monthly into their current account, and that year-on-year CPI (consumer price inflation) is running at 4.6% (as it was at the end of February). The pensioner covers their living expenses with the interest earned on the R1 million.

A year later, they would still have R1 million, but because of inflation, the purchasing power of that R1 million has diminished. The cost of living has risen and, with inflation at 4.5%, the R1 million is worth only R956 000 in terms of what it can buy.

In the current situation they would be earning, say, only 4% interest. If they spend the same as before, they would eat into their R1 million capital, leaving just R969 000 at the end of the year. With inflation running at 2.1%, the purchasing power of that money would have diminished to R950 000.

Therefore, practically, these pensioners are hardly worse off than before: a negligible 0.6% change, as the lower interest income is mostly offset by corresponding lower inflation.

Still, our example underlines the fallacy of this approach. Living off interest income may create the illusion that the underlying capital is being preserved but, in truth, the purchasing power of that money is being steadily eroded.

Cash is considered a low-risk investment because it provides an almost-certain return over the contract period. However, that return is also typically quite low. Savers are usually only compensated for inflation, plus a little bit extra, say 1.5-2.5%.

The slight loss in wealth in our example above reflects the narrowing of that ‘little bit extra’, otherwise known as the real or after-inflation return. In our example, it has contracted from 2.4% to 1.9%. This presents the bigger risk in the long term.  Earning a lower real interest rate over a number of years without a cut in spending uses up savings more quickly.

Additionally, pensioners may find that their expenses have a higher inflation rate, accelerating that depletion.

Indeed, the real issue facing these pensioners is not the current decline in interest rates, but the prospect that inflation starts to increase again, while the Reserve Bank is unable to raise interest rates because our economic circumstances don’t allow it.  Pensioners then face the threat of outliving their savings.

Although every household should have an emergency cash reserve to see them through difficult periods like this one, cash is not the ‘safe’ option for investors with a long-term perspective. This includes retirees, who, depending on their age, might still have an investment time horizon of a couple of decades or more.

Diversification as a hedge against risk

Cash leaves them fully exposed to the negative consequences of declining real interest rates. Diversifying into other asset classes would hedge them against this risk.

Furthermore, cash typically delivers lower long-term returns than other asset classes. Relying on cash alone, therefore, increases the risk that pensioners suffer a decline in lifestyle in the future.

Although it may make their portfolio’s performance more volatile over shorter periods, diversifying across asset classes should better protect them from inflation and concentration risk, ultimately making their savings last longer.

Such diversification is easily achieved by investing in a low-cost balanced multi-asset fund, which can also facilitate automatic monthly income payouts.

Even if they opted for a low-equity fund, they would still have earned some 2% more p.a. than from the money markets over the last 10 years and would now have 24% more money ‒ not to mention the additional peace of mind from knowing that all their eggs were not in one basket.

This post was based on a press release issued on behafl of 10X Investments.

4 Comments

  1. Maya advisors are not necessarily objective in their advice
    what is crucial for us is whether investments should be for terms longer or shorter than 5 years
    so do I go for an annuity or a fixed deposit

    Reply
    • If you are talking about a guaranteed annuity in retirement – they are offering very good rates relative to interest rates. This is because they are priced off government bonds on the current interest rate. A bit technical but you will get a better rate with a guaranteed annuity than a fixed deposit. However, you are effectively buying an insurance product with the agreement that they will pay you an amount for the rest of your life. You can never get back the lump sum once you have purchased an annuity.

      Reply
  2. Thank you for this information. I am 75 (hubby 76)
    House and car paid
    I would like advice on taking out an annuity please

    Reply
    • You would need to speak to a financial adviser who could pull some comparative quotes.

      Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Maya Fisher-French author of Money Questions Answered

Previous Articles

The effects of delaying your retirement

What if you could change your retirement by working just one more year? André Wentzel, Head Client Solutions Savings at Sanlam, explains how delaying your retirement by one, three or five years could fundamentally change your savings and enable a better quality of...

Treasury says “no” to pension loan proposal

National Treasury has made it clear that it does not support any calls to allow members to borrow money from their pension funds. This was in response to a Private Member’s Bill to amend the Pension Funds Act. This Bill was put forward by DA MP Dr Dion George as a...

Fancy new car or a fabulous retirement?

Khwezi Jackson, investment consultant at 10X Investments, explains how buying a fancy new car could sabotage your retirement funding. Seeing a headline, ‘Spending R10,000 per month on a new car’, got me thinking: Why would anyone spend that much money every month to...

Video: The true cost of cashing in your pension

Do you know the true future cost of cashing in your pension? The long-term consequences are not reversible and will leave many financially destitute when it comes to retirement. This video, as part of a member education series for the Government Employees’ Pension...

Video: Make sure you receive your retirement benefits on time

As you enter retirement, one of your biggest risks is a delay between when you receive your final salary and the first payment from your pension. This video, as part of a member education series for the Government Employees’ Pension Fund (GEPF), explains what you need...

Video: Changes to provident funds

On 1 March 2021 the Taxation Laws Amendment Bill of 2020 came into effect. It contains changes that have a direct impact on the members of provident funds. These changes are part of a process to simplify the retirement fund industry and bring provident funds in line...

Supporting your retired parents

Many retirees have not saved enough to meet their financial needs, leaving children with the burden of supporting their retired parents. A retirement survey by Sanlam found that 51% of retirees cannot make ends meet, and one-third do not have enough money to cover...

The true cost of cashing in your pension

Have you heard of the term Sdudla? I recently came across it in relation to members of the GEPF, specifically members who are teachers and nurses. This is the practice of resigning from your post to access your pension fund. As teachers and nurses can work as...

Think before you plunder your retirement fund

Right now you may be feeling overwhelmed by debt, but the impact of drawing on your retirement fund will leave you financially destitute at a very vulnerable time in your life when you may be too old to work. You may not have many options in terms of earning an income...

Make sure you receive your retirement benefits on time

As you enter retirement, one of your biggest risks is that you could experience a delay between when you receive your final paycheque and the first payment from your pension. This is true in both the private and public sectors and managing this transition should form...

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This