You are Here > Home > My Money > Sole proprietor vs private company: which should you choose?

Sole proprietor vs private company: which should you choose?

Jan 25, 2021

By Ruan van Jaarsveld, Manager at Hobbs Sinclair Advisory.

Sole proprietor vs private company: which should you choose?Many South Africans have recently found themselves feeling the need to venture into business outside of the formal, corporate framework. Reasons for this vary, from being retrenched from a salaried position to having to supplement employment income with another income stream.

Most new business ventures start out as sole proprietorships, the simplest form of business entity. But is a sole proprietor the best entity to run a small business and what should you consider before setting up a private company for your business?


The administrative costs to set up a private company and to maintain company secretarial as well as financial reporting requirements should not be underestimated.

A good benchmark is that at least 3% of a company’s annual turnover should be spent on maintaining and reporting of financial and administrative systems to ensure compliance and accuracy of the financial information.

Many small businesses see financial and admin requirements as an unnecessary evil and neglect this expense. This leads to inaccurate and outdated information being used in decision-making – a proven recipe for corporate suicide.

Risk and financial liability

In a sole proprietor structure, the business is run in the name of the owner. There is thus no distinction or separation between the assets and liabilities of the owner and the assets and liabilities of the business.

Taking on any form of risk in the furtherance of a sole proprietorship, whether that is financial risk in the form of loan financing or product risk in the form of selling products that could lead to the business being sued, could lead to the owner being held personally liable for the liabilities of the business.

A private company takes the form of a separate legal entity and thus limits the personal liability that its owners (shareholders) could be subjected to.


It may also be favourable for a sole proprietor to switch to a private company to enable the business to register for VAT. This arrangement could create a benefit for the company by allowing the company to claim input VAT on vatable expenses incurred.

It is, however, very important to consider the VAT status of your target market. Once a company is registered for VAT, it has to charge output VAT of 15% on any taxable supplies (sales) it makes.

While customers who are registered for VAT may in turn claim this 15% back as input VAT, non-VAT registered customers would not be allowed to claim input VAT and would practically experience an increase in your selling price of 15%.

It is mandatory for a business to register for VAT if the total value of taxable supplies made in any consecutive 12-month period exceeded or is likely to exceed R1 million.

A business may also choose to register voluntarily for VAT if the value of taxable supplies made or to be made is less than R1 million, but has exceeded R50 000 in the preceding 12 months.

Income Tax

Income earned by a sole proprietor is included in the taxable income of the individual owner of the business. This means that the business income is taxed, along with the owner’s other forms of income, according to the sliding scale of income tax rates applicable to individuals:

Individual income tax table

Private companies are subject to South Africa’s corporate tax rate of 28%, irrespective of the amount of taxable income earned by the company.

From the above you can gather that, once the taxable income earned by your business exceeds approx. R660 000, it would be more tax efficient to form a company and be liable for tax at 28% of the taxable income earned.

SARS provides further relief for small business in the form of Small Business Corporations (SBC) tax. To qualify as an SBC, a company must comply with the following requirements:

  1. All shareholders are natural persons.
  2. All shareholders hold no shares in any other private company.
  3. All members hold no members’ interest in any other Close Corporation.
  4. Gross income for the year of assessment does not exceed R20 million.
  5. Not more than 20% of the gross income and all the capital gains consist collectively of investment income and income rendering a personal service.

It is important to note that a personal service company includes most freelance services and “any service in the field of accounting, actuarial science, architecture, auctioneering, auditing, broadcasting, consulting, draughtsmanship, education, engineering, financial service broking, health, information technology, journalism, law, management, real estate broking, research, sport, surveying, translation, valuation or veterinary science, which is performed personally by any person who holds an interest in the company or Close Corporation, except where such small business corporation employs three or more unconnected full-time employees for core operations.”

Any of these types of businesses would not qualify as an SBC in terms of tax.

SARS applies the following sliding scale of rates to companies that qualify as SBCs:

SBC tax tables

With the favourable tax rates applicable to SBCs compared to the tax rates applicable to individuals, it would be very tax efficient to switch any business that qualifies as an SBC from a sole proprietor to a private company.

This article was written by By Ruan van Jaarsveld, Manager at Hobbs Sinclair Advisory.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Maya Fisher-French author of Money Questions Answered

Previous Articles

E-cigarettes and your life insurance policy

Clyde Parsons, Actuarial Executive at BrightRock, explains why regular users of e-cigarettes are charged smoker rates by life insurers, and what you can do about it. For decades now, we’ve known that smoking is bad for our health – the research has conclusively shown...

Listen: Creating a passive income with shares

In this podcast, Maya (@mayaonmoney) chats to money blogger Brett (@ETFenthusiast) on how blogging helps keep him on track financially, his plans in working towards financial freedom, and which investments he is using to provide a passive income in the future.

You don’t need a lot of money to start investing

Many people feel they need to have a lot of money in order to start investing. In fact, the opposite is true. Investing small amounts every month actually provides the best risk-return scenario when it comes to longer-term investing. Investing via a monthly debit...

Beware the unpaid CGT shock

Many taxpayers may not be aware that the payment of capital gains tax (CGT) is due before you receive your investment tax certificates. This affects existing provisional taxpayers as well as any resident taxpayer who disposes of an asset and earns a capital gain or...

Teach your kids the value of money

The best financial legacy you can leave your children is to teach them the value of money - how to save it as well as how to spend it, says Stephen Katzenellenbogen, Senior Executive and Wealth Manager at NFB Wealth Management. You don’t have to wait until you die to...

How will the recent looting affect the rand?

Bianca Botes, Director at Foreign Exchange Specialists Citadel Global, shares her insights on the recent protests and looting, and what it might mean for the value of the rand. One cannot deny the chaos that has ensued since the recent incarceration of former South...

Listen: It’s tax time: here’s what you need to know

Tax filing season opened on 1 July, and non-provisional taxpayers have until 23 November to file their returns. Some people look forward to tax season because they can get a rebate, but for many of us it can feel a bit overwhelming. A particular hot topic this year is...

Tips for expats to get tax ready

Tanya Tosen, Master Mobility Specialist at Tax Consulting SA, has some tips for expats to make sure they have all their ducks in a row when it's time to file their tax return. Adding to the challenges of 2020, the South African Revenue Services (SARS) announced that...

Make the right choices from the start

The great thing about getting your first paycheque is that you have the opportunity to do the right things before the bad habits kick in. The day that first paycheque hits your bank account you feel like you have finally arrived. But how you manage that money will...

Are banks putting customers first?

Banks were in the spotlight recently with the release of the annual report by the Ombudsman for Banking Services (OBS) and feedback from the Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA) regarding the banks’ adherence to the Conduct Standard. The draft Conduct Standard...

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This