You are Here > My Car > Fancy new car or a fabulous retirement?

Fancy new car or a fabulous retirement?

Mar 22, 2021

Khwezi Jackson, investment consultant at 10X Investments, explains how buying a fancy new car could sabotage your retirement funding.

Fancy new car or a fabulous retirement?Seeing a headline, ‘Spending R10,000 per month on a new car’, got me thinking: Why would anyone spend that much money every month to pay off a car? A car is a depreciating asset that is said to lose as much as 30% of its value as it is driven out of the showroom.

According to the Automobile Association (AA), “a new car loses value as soon as you drive off the forecourt and by the end of the first year will have lost around 40% of its value.”

Cars were made to help us get from point A to point B conveniently, but over time, they have become a symbol of success. We have come to associate how wealthy an individual is with how expensive and current their car is.

Many people fall prey to peer pressure. In order to appear successful to their peers, they end up with monthly vehicle payments that make up a large proportion of their expenses.

It makes much more sense to buy a vehicle that sets you back R4 000 or R5 000 a month on car finance repayments and put the rest of the money into a long-term savings vehicle.

Immediately, you are looking at saving R50 000 – R60 000 a year ‒ and that is just on the saving on the repayment. When choosing a new car people often neglect to consider the additional costs of owning an expensive vehicle: insurance, fuel, tyres, servicing and so on. A car with a monthly repayment of R10 000 can easily end up costing R15 000 per month all-in.

The real benefit of putting this money into a long-terms savings account is that it will grow over the years into a pot of money you might not have been able to imagine saving.

The satisfaction of watching your nest egg grow rather than watching the value of your wheels depreciate as your car ages will be a lot more fulfilling than being seen driving a fancy car (that your real friends will know you can’t really afford anyway).

Tax savings

Also, if you decide to put the money you save into a retirement fund, you can expect to get some money back from the taxman, who likes to reward smart money moves.

Whatever amount you put towards a retirement annuity or a pension or provident fund comes off the annual total earnings you are taxed on. If you earn R500 000 a year and contribute R50 000 to your retirement fund, you are taxed on only R450 000. (This illustrates the principle only – in reality your tax calculation will probably include other deductions too.)

At current tax rates, in the example above, saving R50 000 for retirement in a year would mean a tax deduction or refund of R18 000. This means that your R50 000 contribution (towards your own retirement) costs you only R32 000. That means a monthly contribution of around R4 200 to your retirement fund costs you a little less than R2 700 a month.

The more you can save from an early age towards your retirement, the more you will benefit from the positive effects of compound growth. For example, an investment of R50,000 when you are 25 years old is likely to be worth more than R2.5 million by the time you reach 65.

If we keep using our hard-earned money to respond to our short-term desires rather than our long-term needs – things like owning your own home and having enough money to live a decent life when you reach retirement age – we are setting ourselves up for a life of short-lived pleasure and long-term regret.

The next time you want to buy an expensive phone contract, car, furniture, clothes, or a holiday on credit, think of the impact that this decision will have on your future self.

Every rand saved today matters and will have a huge impact on your long-term success. Don’t indulge in short-term gratification but start saving now so you can enjoy the fruits of your labour at retirement age.

This article first appeared in City Press.


  1. Often a 25 year old will not have that example amount to save in the RA and the escalations can be hard on a pocket as the years go by especially when people are not getting 10%plus increases and then when children are a factor the amounts also starts looking impossible to put away. Unless you have a benefit with a company that helps you with 40-50% of the amount which in today’s world is not realistic. Intact medical aid is going through the roof and is costing more than an RA as medical aid is becoming a necessity as fines are imposed if not taken on immediately after leaving home and the family’s medical aid.

    • It is obviously just a generalization to highlight the money decisions we come across each day and how to assess those. Very good point on the cost of medical aid – it is definitely getting way above our ability to keep paying.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Maya Fisher-French author of Money Questions Answered

Previous Articles

Video: Why it pays to be a member of the GEPF

As a financial journalist I am increasingly concerned about misinformation provided to members of the Government Employees Pension Fund (GEPF) by unscrupulous financial advisers. Some advisers use fear tactics, telling members that their funds will be stolen or...

What is the tax benefit of an RA?

A reader asked: “I am 38 years old and I am not happy with the returns on my Retirement Annuity (RA). I am considering scaling down my monthly contributions and rather investing the money offshore myself through a stockbroker. What are the tax differences once I reach...

No early access for GEPF members

Any changes relating to early access to funds in a private-sector pension fund or RA will have no bearing on members of the GEPF. I have received many queries from readers about the proposal to allow members of retirement funds limited access to their retirement funds...

The best way to settle your car finance

Advance payments on car finance do not work the same as on your home loan, so it’s worth understanding how to make the most of it. Any debt that you pay off sooner than required will save you money on interest. However, you need to understand how advance payments work...

Why it pays to be a member of the GEPF

As a financial journalist I am increasingly concerned about misinformation provided to members of the Government Employees’ Pension Fund (GEPF) by unscrupulous financial advisers. A recent example is a reader who was told by an adviser that on retiring after 20 years...

Listen: What you need to know about car finance

How does a balloon payment work? What questions should I ask my dealer? Can I settle my car finance early and what happens if I want to give my car back? Maya (@mayaonmoney) chats to vehicle financing expert Henry Botha of Absa Vehicle and Asset finance to answer...

Reclassification of inward-listed ETFs – what it means for you

The market is alight with speculation over a statement which quietly crept into Finance Minister Tito Mboweni's recent medium-term budget policy statement around the reclassification of inward-listed financial products. National Treasury has made a decision to...

Early access to pensions mooted

Legislation will be introduced to allow early access to one's pension, but it's not an end-of-year bonus. In the medium-term budget address, Finance Minister Tito Mboweni confirmed that National Treasury will be introducing legislative changes to allow early access to...

Is your retirement fund safe from plunder?

Many South Africans believe that their retirement funds are under attack. Financial planners are inundated with queries from concerned clients and some are even stopping their retirement contributions. Is this fear well founded or an over-reaction to media headlines?...

Video: Car and handbag insurance for women

I always maintain that actuaries never lie, and women on average pay less for car insurance than men, so is it true that women are better drivers? In light of Women's Month, I am speaking to Christelle Colman of Elite Wealth Assets Insurance to explain why women pay...

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This