You are Here > Home > My Retirement > Proposed additional exit tax leaves industry experts confused

Proposed additional exit tax leaves industry experts confused

Aug 26, 2021

Tax Consulting SA gives the lowdown on a new draft tax bill which essentially proposes an additional exit tax on retirement funds.

Proposed additional exit tax leaves industry experts confusedIt is not uncommon for National Treasury and the South African Revenue Services (SARS) to propose, and subsequently gazette, amendments to the Income Tax Law.

These draft tax law amendment bills are open for public comment before being signed into law, and are thus usually scrutinised in detail by industry specialists.

Once such proposed amendment has left experts across the finance, tax and emigration industries very confused about the road ahead.

Taxing retirement interests on cessation of residency

The Taxation Laws Amendment Bill proposes the introduction of section 9HC, which is directed at taxing retirement interests on cessation of residency.

Tax Consulting SA’s Head of Tax Technical, Jean du Toit, explains this amendment as follows:

“This amendment seeks to prevent retirement interests from escaping taxation in SA after a person ceases residency. It is proposed that an individual will be deemed to have withdrawn from their retirement fund on the day before they cease residency, triggering a South African tax liability.

“In effect, it proposes to impose an exit charge on retirement interests, in addition to the existing exit tax that finds application when a person ceases residency.

“It is important to note that the payment of the tax is deferred to when the amount is actually receivable from the retirement fund. In other words, the tax is triggered on the day before the person ceases residency but is payable only upon withdrawal.

“The tax will be levied on the value of the interest on the day prior to ceasing residency and will be calculated in terms of the lump sum tax tables prevailing at the time of payment. If enacted, this provision will come into operation on 1 March 2022.”

In layperson’s terms, SARS has tabled an additional exit tax on retirement funds, that will be levied at point of emigration (or cessation of tax residency) and be payable on the day of receiving the lump sum payment, with no indication as to what tax tables would be used when the calculation is done.

“By structuring the tax in this way, the new provision effectively circumvents the network of double tax treaties concluded with certain other countries.

“While National Treasury has been transparent about the reason for introducing this tax, it is not quite clear how Government has reconciled itself with the potential double taxation that may result, or the fact that it may flout South Africa’s treaty obligations,” added du Toit.

The consequences of the draft tax bill

At the receiving end of these amendments are expatriates who are contemplating a more permanent move to another country, not to mention the hopeful South African taxpayers who wanted to retire abroad.

According to Barry Pretorius from the Expat Tax Petition Group (TPG), the decision is incredibly vexing, and once signed into law, the effects of the propsed new exit tax could be detrimental to expatriates once they give up their South African tax residency.

“Since this additional exit tax will be calculated in terms of tax tables only prevailing when the interest is withdrawn, it’s not known if the current tax rates may apply when the tax finally becomes payable,” says Pretorius, a long-standing advocate for South African taxpayers working or living abroad.

“In cases where a double taxation agreement gives sole taxing right over retirement fund interests to a host country, it’s unclear if that country will recognise this additional tax given that it could conflict with the provisions of the DTA.

“Should the new country of residence not provide a tax credit for the South African tax on the basis that it conflicts with the DTA, it will lead to double taxation for expats on withdrawn retirement fund interests.”

Adding to the woes of the draft tax bills is the fact that the three-year lock-in rule, which came into effect in 1 March 2021, will remain in place. The lock-in rule means South Africans generally have to wait for three years after ceasing their tax residency to access their money in a retirement annuity.

Knock-on effect across other laws

Harry Joffe, Head of Legal Services at Discovery Life, was concerned that Treasury has set themselves a very daunting timeframe within which to finalise and implement the proposed additional exit tax, especially since it will have a knock-on effect across other laws.

“The regulatory framework that is impacted by this decision is so vast. By changing one provision in the Income Tax Act that affects pension funds and retirement funds, it triggers a lot of laws and regulations that would have to be reviewed.

“Amendments to the Pension Funds Act would have to be made. Retirement funds would have to change their rules. Clarity surrounding taxation in terms of the Second Schedule on lump sum benefits would have to be provided.

“In addition, the whole system of tax directives would be affected. I simply can’t see it materializing by 1 March 2022,” says Joffe.

While industry leaders are trying to better interpret the implication of the proposed additional exit tax, many are wondering if this will lead to the three-year lock-in rule being scrapped.

“Running this tax concurrently with the three-year lock-in rule seems very unfair to retirement fund members who are paying tax and interest on assets they can’t access,” says Joffe.

Opportunity to comment

Given that the draft bill is open to public and stakeholder comment, Tax Consulting SA has taken it upon themselves to launch a technical submission to parliament to oppose the draft tax bill from being signed into law.

This provides an opportunity for South African taxpayers living abroad, who often find themselves isolated in another country, to voice their concerns about excessive taxation on their savings.

To add your comment to the submission, complete the TPG survey.

This post was based on a press release issued on behalf of Tax Consulting SA.


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Maya Fisher-French author of Money Questions Answered

Previous Articles

Five ways to boost your income and financial knowledge

Angelique Ruzicka shares five ideas for how you can improve your financial knowledge and possibly boost your income. Boosting your income, especially during a pandemic, can feel nigh on impossible, especially when costs are going up and you’ve been told there’s no...

Financial tools to keep you on track in 2022

Advances in technology mean that it’s now so easy to keep track of your finances and achieve savings goals, using smartphone apps, websites, and other online financial tools, says Angelique Ruzicka. If you’re still using Excel or some other rudimentary means to keep...

What will the rand do in 2022?

Ryan Booysen, MD at DG Capital Forex, stares into his crystal ball to predict where the rand will go in 2022. The rand ended 2021 on the back foot, after the Omicron announcement and subsequent global kneejerk reaction of isolation and red-listing the country. And...

SARS gets serious over non-compliance

Jashwin Baijoo, Legal Manager, Africa Tax and Compliance at Tax Consulting SA, warns all non-compliant taxpayers that SARS could be coming for them sooner rather than later. In media statements in recent months, the South African Revenue Service (SARS) has made clear...

Should I use my retirement lump sum to settle my debt?

A question that I often receive is whether it's a good idea to use one's lump sum on retirement to pay off short-term debts, such as car debt or one's credit card. For example, Ntombise recently wrote to me: “I have just retired from work and expect a lump sum...

Reflecting on the year that was

Victoria Reuvers, Managing Director at Morningstar Investment Management South Africa, looks at how financial markets performed in 2021. As a runner, the change in seasons gives me time to reflect. Autumn is my favourite season, and always reminds me that change is...

Immediate access to retirement funds unlikely

Retirement reform paper calls for comment but no move on immediate access. Retirement fund members hoping to access their retirement funds for urgent financial relief will be disappointed by the retirement reform paper issued by National Treasury last month. In the...

The 2022 survival budget

As if the last two years were not tough enough, there is no silver lining awaiting us in 2022. In 2021 we absorbed further fuel-price increases, a 15% hike in electricity costs, and an interest-rate increase of 25 basis points – and this is only the start. It is...

Using critical illness insurance to supplement medical cover

Many financial advisers are using life products to supplement medical costs. While current legislation does not allow for cover like critical illness insurance to be marketed as a product to cover medical costs, for most policyholders, that is exactly what it is used...

Savvy ways to use your bonus

Many companies are cash strapped due to the impact of Covid-19, but if you are one of the lucky few who got a bonus or windfall this year, it will be tempting to spend it to celebrate surviving another tough year. However, money experts recommend being a bit cautious,...

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This