You are Here > Home > My Money > Government withdraws proposal to impose exit tax on retirement interests

Government withdraws proposal to impose exit tax on retirement interests

Nov 12, 2021

Jean du Toit, Head of Tax Technical at Tax Consulting SA, explains why Government had no choice but to backtrack on the proposed exit tax on retirement interests.

Government withdraws proposal to impose exit tax on retirement interestsExpatriates and those with plans to emigrate will be relieved to learn that the proposal to impose an exit tax on retirement interests will be withdrawn.

In presenting their Draft Response Document on the 2021 Draft Tax Bills, National Treasury and SARS confirmed that the proposal will not be included in final Taxation Laws Amendment Bill that will be tabled in the Medium Term Budget.

The proposed exit tax

The 2021 Draft Tax Bills were published in July this year and arguably the most contentious proposal tabled was the imposition of an exit tax on retirement interests when a South African taxpayer ceases residency.

The reason for the proposed tax was that SARS may in certain instances lose out on the right to tax retirement interests of taxpayers if they cease South African tax residency.

The concern lies in the wording of certain double tax treaties that allocate the sole taxing right on these amounts to the country where the taxpayer is resident.

To counter the loss to the fiscus in these cases, it was proposed to trigger a tax on the value of the taxpayer’s retirement interest on the day before the person ceases residency. The tax would only be due to SARS when the benefit becomes payable in future. The proposal was met with fierce opposition.

Expatriates fight back

The proposal constituted an amendment that was again directed at a group of taxpayers that have been affected by year-on-year changes to our tax legislation.

The Expatriate Petition Group, as representative of this group of individuals and with an active membership of 15 000 people, again pulled together to oppose the proposal.

In submissions submitted by Tax Consulting SA on behalf of the EPG, it was delineated that the proposal adds to the narrative of marginalisation of the expatriate population and it would further alienate an important part of the South African tax base. But the submission also highlighted other challenges facing the proposal.

Most notably, the proposal was designed to subvert the provisions of the double tax treaties concluded with some of our treaty partners.

For a country that has always respected treaty obligations, this would be unprecedented. Enacting domestic legislation to override treaty provisions flouts not only the agreement with the relevant treaty partner but also South Africa’s good faith obligations under the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties.

From the taxpayer’s perspective, the knock-on effect would be double taxation, without any recourse, as the tax levied in South Africa would be illegitimate.

This would not be the only hardship faced by the taxpayer, as the proposed section would force the individual to incur interest on the postponed tax. Ultimately, the proposal faced a cascade of insurmountable challenges.

Warnings heeded by Government

During their feedback session ahead of the Medium Term Budget, National Treasury acknowledged the validity of the comments raised, particularly the concerns around violating international treaty obligations.

It was further noted that the proposal will be revisited in subsequent legislative cycles, as this problem must, somehow, be addressed.

While we may see the proposal back on the table in future, the problem can likely only be fixed by renegotiating existing treaties, which will not happen overnight.

Be that as it may, National Treasury’s willingness to engage the public in the law-making process must be applauded, and the fact that the EPG’s warnings were heeded is a most welcome development.

This post was based on a press release, issued on behalf of Tax Consulting South Africa.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Maya Fisher-French author of Money Questions Answered

Previous Articles

The ‘silent’ changes affecting South Africans who are emigrating

The transition from the old emigration regime to the current regime ‒ ceasing of tax residency ‒ came with some relief. However, there were some changes that went largely unnoticed. By Lovemore Ndlovu, SARS and Exchange Control Specialist at Tax Consulting SA, and...

Vote for your GEPF trustees

The Government Employees Pension Fund (GEPF) will be holding its elections for new trustees from January to May 2022. GEPF elections are held every four years and are an opportunity for pensioners and members of the South African National Defence Force (SANDF) and...

Five ways to boost your income and financial knowledge

Angelique Ruzicka shares five ideas for how you can improve your financial knowledge and possibly boost your income. Boosting your income, especially during a pandemic, can feel nigh on impossible, especially when costs are going up and you’ve been told there’s no...

Financial tools to keep you on track in 2022

Advances in technology mean that it’s now so easy to keep track of your finances and achieve savings goals, using smartphone apps, websites, and other online financial tools, says Angelique Ruzicka. If you’re still using Excel or some other rudimentary means to keep...

What will the rand do in 2022?

Ryan Booysen, MD at DG Capital Forex, stares into his crystal ball to predict where the rand will go in 2022. The rand ended 2021 on the back foot, after the Omicron announcement and subsequent global kneejerk reaction of isolation and red-listing the country. And...

SARS gets serious over non-compliance

Jashwin Baijoo, Legal Manager, Africa Tax and Compliance at Tax Consulting SA, warns all non-compliant taxpayers that SARS could be coming for them sooner rather than later. In media statements in recent months, the South African Revenue Service (SARS) has made clear...

Should I use my retirement lump sum to settle my debt?

A question that I often receive is whether it's a good idea to use one's lump sum on retirement to pay off short-term debts, such as car debt or one's credit card. For example, Ntombise recently wrote to me: “I have just retired from work and expect a lump sum...

Reflecting on the year that was

Victoria Reuvers, Managing Director at Morningstar Investment Management South Africa, looks at how financial markets performed in 2021. As a runner, the change in seasons gives me time to reflect. Autumn is my favourite season, and always reminds me that change is...

Immediate access to retirement funds unlikely

Retirement reform paper calls for comment but no move on immediate access. Retirement fund members hoping to access their retirement funds for urgent financial relief will be disappointed by the retirement reform paper issued by National Treasury last month. In the...

The 2022 survival budget

As if the last two years were not tough enough, there is no silver lining awaiting us in 2022. In 2021 we absorbed further fuel-price increases, a 15% hike in electricity costs, and an interest-rate increase of 25 basis points – and this is only the start. It is...

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This